"It's really good here," shrimp boat captain Drew Sawyer told First Coast News after bringing his boat into Mayport Village from four days at sea. "That's why I'm here. I told you I'm from North Carolina, but I'm here. It's better than anywhere on the East Coast." He estimated the haul at six or seven thousand pounds of shrimp.
Catches like that come in at the mouth of the St. Johns River, and the name travels well beyond it. "Mayport shrimp" shows up on menus all over Jacksonville. When researchers DNA-tested shrimp dishes across the area, they found something different on most plates. With the best part of the local season coming in November and December, it helps to know which kitchens passed.
What the DNA tests found on Jacksonville plates
SeaD Consulting ran the study for the Southern Shrimp Alliance, and News4JAX reported the findings in March 2026. Researchers took shrimp dishes from 44 randomly selected restaurants and seafood markets in the Jacksonville area. Fourteen, or 32%, were confirmed as authentic American wild-caught shrimp. The other 30, or 68%, were imported or farm-raised.
Serving imported or farm-raised shrimp was not the main issue. Of the 30 places doing so, 3 said so on the menu. Two were unsure where their shrimp came from. At the remaining 25, the menu or the staff described the shrimp as local, Mayport, or American wild-caught, and testing showed it was imported. On average, diners paid about $2 more per plate for those dishes than for the authentic ones.
"There's nothing wrong with serving farm-raised shrimp, but what is wrong is when you claim it's local shrimp, which most people are willing to pay a little more for," Mike Eddy of Beacon Fisheries told News4JAX.
Six of those 25 places were on Visit Jacksonville's Mayport Shrimp & Seafood Trail. According to the trail's toolkit for businesses, restaurants can apply if they serve Mayport shrimp or locally caught fish or seafood. The toolkit doesn't mention any genetic testing or origin check. The researchers also pointed out that most states that produce warmwater shrimp have passed seafood labeling laws, and Florida has not. After the study came out, the Southern Shrimp Alliance asked lawmakers to consider one, Florida Politics reported. We couldn't find a 2026 bill on the subject that has become law. For now, a menu description is the restaurant's own claim.
The fourteen that passed, and the three closest to the docks
The study didn't release the names of the places that failed. Those businesses may be reported to the Florida Department of Agriculture. It did list the 14 places whose shrimp tested as authentic American wild-caught. That's the most useful map a Jacksonville shrimp eater has right now. One limit to keep in mind is that "American wild-caught" means the shrimp came from U.S. waters. It doesn't prove a given plate came off a Mayport boat.
Three of the 14 are within a short drive of where the boats come in:
- Safe Harbor Seafood Restaurant, 4378 Ocean St. in Mayport, sits beside the commercial docks. The City of Jacksonville describes it as the anchor of the seafood supply chain there.
- Singleton's Seafood Shack, 4728 Ocean St., is farther up the same street. Its online menu includes a fried shrimp dinner, a steamed shrimp basket and Shrimpwreck Shrimp.
- Mayport C&C Fisheries Seafood Market, 36 W. 6th St., is the place to go if you'd rather cook at home. Despite the name, it's in Atlantic Beach, not the village.
The rest of the list covers much of the city: AJ's Seafood on Arlington Road North, Beachside Seafood, Grouper Shack and Land Shark Bar & Grill in Jacksonville Beach, Blue Fish Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Avondale, Fisherman's Dock Seafood Market and Julington Creek Fish Camp on San Jose Boulevard, Marker 32 on Beach Boulevard, New Berlin Fish House & Oyster Bar, Seafood Express & More on North Main Street, and Voodoo Brewing Co. in San Marco.
The list reflects one round of samples taken before March 2026. Kitchens change suppliers, so treat it as a starting point and still ask your server.
November and December are when the trip pays off
Visit Jacksonville says Mayport shrimp is caught where the St. Johns River meets the Atlantic. It can be white or brown, and while it's available fresh all year, the best and biggest shrimp come in November and December. Commercial shrimping has shaped life in Mayport Village for more than 150 years.
So the shrimp are at their best in the weeks right before the year turns, and a few village changes fall into that same window.
The docks the catch comes across are about to be rebuilt
On June 30, 2026, the City of Jacksonville announced $11,210,471 for Mayport Dock Redevelopment Phase II. The city puts the total project cost at about $14 million, with the city providing a non-federal match of roughly $2.8 million. It pays for new mooring structures, a reinforced concrete deck, power pedestals, water service and solar lighting at the commercial dock, First Coast News reported. According to the city, the work will add room for more boats, cut down on flooding that disrupts operations, and protect the seafood supply chain that runs through Safe Harbor and other commercial operators. The announcement didn't give a completion date.
Sawyer listed what keeps him in Mayport this way: "Ice, fuel, water. Got a nice restaurant right there, good guy we sell our shrimp to over there." His reaction to the upgrade was "Two thumbs up from me."
Other plans are in earlier stages. A Mayport Action Plan dated February 2026 proposes walkability, parking and safety improvements on Ocean Street, a riverfront greenway and a living shoreline. It's a planning document, not a construction schedule. The Mayport Lighthouse Association has shared that a feasibility study found the St. Johns River Lighthouse could be moved to a city waterfront parcel near the ferry terminal. That move still needs approvals and funding, at a rough estimate of $4.8 million to $6 million.
A Mayport Saturday, before the ferry fare goes up
The Mayport Waterfront Partnership runs the Mayport Waterfront Market on the third Saturday of every month at 4542 Ocean St. It runs from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., with local vendors, food trucks and a focus on the village's fishing heritage. The rest of 2026 brings three market days, October 17, November 21 and December 19, and the last two fall in peak shrimp season.
A market-day route could look like this:
- Start at the market on Ocean Street when it opens at 10 a.m.
- Take the St. Johns River Ferry to Fort George Island. Boats cross every half hour, from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekends.
- Walk or ride Fort George Island Cultural State Park. It's open 8 a.m. to sunset, and the Fairway Loop trail runs four miles. The Ribault Club is open Wednesday through Sunday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., except Thanksgiving and Christmas.
- Stop at Kingsley Plantation, part of the National Park Service's Timucuan Ecological & Historic Preserve. Admission is free, and the visitor station is open Wednesday through Sunday, 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The grounds include the slave quarters, barn, waterfront, kitchen house and interpretive garden. Access to the planter's house is limited because of structural concerns, and the park service says to call ahead for current details.
- Cross back before the last boat. On the Mayport side, the last departures are 6:30 p.m. on weekdays and 8:30 p.m. on weekends. Then finish with dinner at Safe Harbor or Singleton's.
Ferry fares change on January 1, 2027. A car now costs $7 on weekdays and $8 on weekends. Under the new schedule, those rise to $8 and $10. Motorcycles go to $7, and a 20-trip car ticket book goes to $140. Walk-ons and bicycles stay at $1. JTA's mobile fare discounts already ended on October 1, 2026.
Action News Jax reported that the JTA board approved the fare and service changes on August 27, 2026. According to the Jax Daily Record, the higher fares are part of how the authority planned for a projected $17.5 million shortfall in its fiscal 2027 budget. The same package raises single bus rides to $2, and JTA expected all of the fare increases together to bring in $1.57 million. The November and December market Saturdays are the last two this year at today's car fares.
Restaurant hours posted online aren't always current. Call Safe Harbor and Singleton's to confirm hours, and call Kingsley Plantation about the house, before you set out.
If a November market Saturday in Mayport has you curious what life near the water in Mayport or anywhere along the St. Johns looks like day to day, Donna S Osteen would be glad to talk it through with you. Schedule Your Consultation.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.